Canada

Canada Is Making A “Mistake” That Will Underestimate Inflation: Big Six Bank

Canadian inflation should be smooth sailing, coming in low and stable from now on. A small catch though — your cost of living may not actually see low inflation. Statistics Canada (Stat Can) consumer price index (CPI) data shows an unexpected slowdown in June. The popular interpretation for today’s release is, this proves high inflation is transitory. At least one “Big Six” bank thinks this is most definitely not the case.

National Bank of Canada (NBC) argues recent growth shows acceleration, not a slowing. In a note shared with clients, they explain rising costs are more sticky than presented. Though that may not show up in Canada’s official data.

The bank’s economists warn recent changes in methodology will chronically underestimate inflation. They went so far as to rhetorically ask if the agency thinks this is the best way to serve Canada. That’s basically the economist equivalent of throwing down your hockey stick.

Canadian Inflation Decelerated In June… Sort Of 

Let’s start with the headline numbers that were released. The agency reported CPI increased 0.3% in June, down from the 0.5% increase seen in May. A deceleration was also seen for the annual rates as well.

The annual rate of growth fell to 3.1% in June, down from 3.6% in May. The latter had been the largest print since 2011, so the decline in rising costs was more than welcome. Stat Can attributes the deceleration to the base effect, helping to lower growth. Recent data shows high inflation wasn’t just a base effect issue though.

Canadian Consumer Price Index Basket Weight Change

The annual percent change for the Canadian consumer price index (CPI).

Source: Stat Can; Better Dwelling.

Not Just A Base Effect: Recent Growth Has Been Ripping Higher

NBC economists shared their take, explaining recent inflation has been running hot. The 3-month annualized rate of growth reached 4.4% in June. The 3-month. Recent growth has been higher than the annual rate. To see the annual rate decelerate is a little odd, but the point is, it’s not just a base effect. Inflation has been accelerating recently, not only in comparison to last year.

“While some may point to this latest report as an example that recent inflationary pressures are a transitory phenomenon, we maintain our view that inflation should be somewhat sticky in the medium-term,” said the Big Six bank to its financial markets clients.  

Canada Changed Inflation To “Better” Reflect Pandemic Spending

Last week we discussed changes to the CPI basket weight, and why it would flatten inflation. For those that need a recap, they’re placing more weight in areas that have seen costs soar in 2020. This might sound like a good idea, but the price increases were thought to be transitory. The areas of the basket that gained points, are taking them away from areas where consumption was low… due to artificial constraints.

To be blunt, they’re putting emphasis on areas likely to see a correction in prices. This will make transitory costs seem deflationary. At the same time, they reduced the weight in areas with temporary reductions in spending. This will lower the impact of components where costs are expected to rise. Overall, inflation will be much lower than in reality. One week later, we have our first Big Six bank that agrees with our take.

Stat Can Is Making A “Mistake,” And Will Underestimate Inflation

NBC sent clients a special “methodological note” on the basket update used for June. Stat Can updates the basket every two years, with 2017’s update used to create inflation points up to this past May. They didn’t use a 2019 update they created. Instead, they made another in 2020. Instead of a stable period, they wanted to “better reflect” pandemic spending habits. The emphasis quote was from NBC, in case you’re curious

The bank said this would be a “mistake” to adjust spending habits to a period of unnatural spending. Now the basket reflects spending patterns established in 2020, which were totally normal. Toilet paper, Lysol, cannabis, and liquor are the only things people will buy from now on, right?

As for the areas you didn’t spend on? Those now represent a smaller portion of the inflation basket. “The items whose weights are expected to increase in the consumer basket as the economy reopens (transportation, gasoline, recreation) will therefore occupy too small a place in the new basket,” said the bank’s economists. 

Adding, “since we expect these categories to experience the largest price increases in the near future, official inflation data is likely to keep underestimating inflation pressure going forward.” Stat Can is introducing a statistical bias designed to reduce inflation readings. They’re going to perpetually do it going forward as well.

Canadian Consumer Price Index Basket Weight Change

The point change in the consumer price index (CPI) based weight from 2017 to 2020.

Source: NBC; Stat Can; Better Dwelling.

The agency plans to update the inflation basket on an annual basis from now on. This will constantly increase basket weights for temporary surges, and emphasize corrections. NBC questioned whether this move is of any public value. It certainly doesn’t appear to be.

“We are not sure this is the best way for Statistics Canada to achieve its goal ‘to ensure that the CPI reflects the price change experienced by Canadians’,” they wrote. 

We know, it sounds like just nerd talk, but this can have some serious consequences. Monetary policy is based on CPI, and minimizing it will lead to loose conditions. Stimulus effects become less effective the longer they exist, so this won’t be a boom to the economy. The positives, such as higher consumption, will normalize to an overly loose system.

Instead, the negative consequences would become more pronounced. For example, indexed pay increases wouldn’t capture the reality of rising costs. The same issue crops up with pensioners, who are heavily impacted by inflation. The gap between inflation pay increases and the actual cost of living will compound. This could lead to an even faster rise of inequality, with every basket update.

Like this post? Like us on Facebook for the next one in your feed.

17 Comments

COMMENT POLICY:
We encourage you to have a civil discussion. Note that reads "civil," which means don't act like jerks to each other. Still unclear? No name-calling, racism, or hate speech. Seriously, you're adults – act like it.

Any comments that violates these simple rules, will be removed promptly – along with your full comment history. Oh yeah, you'll also lose further commenting privileges. So if your comments disappear, it's not because the illuminati is screening you because they hate the truth, it's because you violated our simple rules.

  • Lou Chao 2 months ago

    The biggest takeaway here is by far the impact on monetary policy. If inflation should have run at 3.6% and it’s only reported at 3%, it’s running at the top band and requires no cooling. Whereas it still as the impact of higher inflation on everyone’s cost of living.

  • Frank Daugherty 2 months ago

    CPI in my life has never been a reflection of reality. It’s tied to government indexing for pensions and bonds, so of course they find ways to sandbag the numbers.

    • Ahmed 2 months ago

      Waiting for the Federal government to not disclose this change and say it’s a triumph, and they controlled it better than any other country. It’s the poverty reduction strategy again.

      • Terry 2 months ago

        What’s this about the poverty reduction numbers?

        • RW 2 months ago

          Essentially they changed the methodology they use. The preferred method of measuring it is usually the LIM, which basically shows poverty in Canada is cyclical (makes the most sense, since so is wealth). Instead they picked a measure that shows it dropped consistently over time.

          Thanks to BD and CMHC for introducing me to Nick Falvo’s work. He’s an expert that specializes in poverty. Great read on the different measures, although he seems like too nice of a guy on Twitter to ever call out the government on this. Great read. Guy deserves a much bigger audience.

          https://nickfalvo.ca/ten-things-to-know-about-poverty-measurement-in-canada/

      • Charlie Lee 2 months ago

        You’re telling me actually seeing more homeless people spill into the streets to the point where Toronto is now sending in militias to disburse homeless people to try and hide them, isn’t just me not understanding the statistics, like the government and economists say? Shocker.

        • ML 2 months ago

          Canadian government will continue to brain wash newcomers that they are number one in that and this, abusing statistics to their convenience.
          They need more and more slaves to continue their ponzi scheme.
          I better be back in my native Iran than sighn myself ever again for this number one country in the world.

  • Sam 2 months ago

    Not even the cartel could run such a successful scam.

  • Eric Dixon 2 months ago

    Thank gawd for National Bank. Last pinch of sanity in the market. Other banks are already trying to compare it as a triumph over the US management of inflation. Not that they’re doing great.

  • D 2 months ago

    Pay off debts = reduced inflation

  • Kolf 2 months ago

    I thought we have big 5, we have big 6 now so that Stephen here can make his point?

    • expat 2 months ago

      Is the point not relevant or are you upset about something?

    • Paul 2 months ago

      It’s been big six for most of my adult life. Your first dance?

  • Ex 2 months ago

    Quality of life in some third world countries< like in my native Iran, reaching Canadian standards.
    They have more oppurtunities now to make money and spend less time in housing slavery, paying mortgage debt.
    Canadian government needs to put more effort to brainwash newcomers with their fake advertisements. Bradding that Canada is number one in this and in that, with their fake statistics.

  • Tdawg 2 months ago

    So when some of the largest financial institutions call the government out for obvious data manipulation and the status quote remains time and time again, how bad does it have to get for proper action and/or corrections to follow? This goes beyond bubbles.

    This is just a financial dystopia. I feel like we are in a sci fi movie where there is a proper timeline and we are stuck on a weird variant of reality where the hero can’t figure out how to get us back! I don’t think a film called “Inflation Man” would sell many tickets at the box office though!

  • Tdawg 2 months ago

    Supposed to say “status quo” stupid autocorrect!

  • M.Bury 2 months ago

    It is not a “mistake”, it is INTENT.

Comments are closed.