An MP Asked What Ottawa’s Borrowing Costs Canadians. Here’s the Math

How much does Ottawa’s borrowing cost the rest of us, beyond what shows up in the budget? On Thursday, I testified before the House of Commons Standing Committee on Finance as part of its study on federal spending power. After I explained the implications of federal borrowing for credit markets, MP Michael Guglielmin pressed for an estimate. I didn’t have one, but it’s a good question, so I began modelling it as soon as I left the room. It’s even more than I assumed. 

But first, let’s talk about how debt works.  

How Government Borrowing Impacts What You Pay To Borrow

Credit is a market and, like any other, is priced on supply, demand, and risk. When there’s more capital than borrowers, rates fall as lenders compete for business. When borrowing outpaces the capital available, rates rise as borrowers compete for it. Riskier borrowers then pay a premium on top. 

The lowest-risk borrower is the Government of Canada, which issues the currency. It pays the least, and its yield is the benchmark that everyone else’s borrowing is priced from. Someone like, I don’t know, Ricky from the Trailer Park Boys would pay the most because he fell behind on his vig. 

When Ottawa borrows more, it pushes that benchmark up, and everyone pays more as well. Large businesses, small businesses, your car loan, your mortgage—they’re all priced off the same benchmarks. In finance, this is called crowding out. 

Now back to the question. How much extra does this transmission cost, beyond the borrowing itself? 

Households Could Pay Billions In Extra Mortgage Interest

We estimate the projected rise in federal market debt will add roughly 13 to 26 basis points to Canada’s 5-year bond yield. That means households can pay billions in extra interest per year once fully phased in, which isn’t exactly chump change. However, that’s just households—the burden extends to businesses and, ironically, the government’s own future financing. Here’s a high-level overview. 

The most obvious hit would be to residential mortgages—about $3.2B to $6.3B in extra interest, or $190 to $380 per household per year. However, not all households have a mortgage—about 6 million do. That more realistically puts the burden at an average of $530 to $1,050 per year for those with a mortgage, and it would be concentrated among larger and more recent mortgages.  

Applying the same transmission to all household credit puts the upper end at $4.3B to $8.7B per year. That averages about $260 to $520 for each of the 16.6 million households. That doesn’t include the growing use of private lenders, who tend to charge wider spreads as risk compensation. 

We also estimate it would reduce borrowing power by roughly 1.3% to 2.6%. Interestingly, Bank of Canada (BoC) research on higher rates points to about the same decline in home prices over two years. If applied to the housing stock, that works out to roughly $111B to $222B in lost home equity. However, let’s stick to more direct costs, as modelling equity losses is a much deeper rabbit hole. 

The drag on the housing industry is a more complex issue. While Ottawa’s borrowing is designed to stimulate certain aspects of building, it’s likely to hurt market-based outcomes. That doesn’t mean improved affordability either, since a large share is going towards large corporate landlords. Those are the same firms academics warn have outsized market power, raising rents much faster than mom-and-pop landlords. Another MP asked me about supply and affordability, and it deserves its own rundown next week. 

Businesses Can Pay More—Unless They Have Ottawa’s Backing

Businesses face the same transmission. On corporate bonds alone, that’s roughly $1.2B to $2.4B per year in added interest. However, the bigger cost will be investments that no longer clear the higher hurdle rate. In my opening statement, I noted that Ottawa isn’t just providing big businesses with low-cost loans; it’s slanting the odds against the small and medium businesses that employ the majority of Canadian workers. This is part of the fallout: firms with Crown financing are shielded from the higher rate with taxpayer-subsidized loans, while everyone else faces higher costs.  

The Irony: Ottawa’s Interest Bill Grows Too

One of the more interesting points is that this will also cost taxpayers. As federal debt is refinanced at higher yields, interest costs rise by roughly $3.1B to $6.2B a year once fully repriced. We use the 5-year yield as a proxy, since 10-year yields move more and T-bill rates less. The same transmission across federal, provincial and local debt works out to roughly $4.7B to $9.5B a year, ceteris paribus. That last part is a ten-dollar word for all else equal, and if you catch me using it in public, feel free to give me a firm slap.   

There’s also a risk these estimates don’t capture—liquidity. As I noted in my opening statement, a growing share of Government of Canada bonds are absorbed by leveraged hedge funds. If that liquidity disappears, as it did in March 2020, the Bank of Canada has historically stepped in to buy—the same intervention that left it with roughly $10B in accumulated losses by the end of 2025. 

Sounds like a banker’s wet dream, doesn’t it? 

Note

Our estimates use research from the CBO, Federal Reserve and Dallas Fed, which finds each point of debt-to-GDP adds 2 to 4 basis points to long-term yields. We scaled that to the 5-year yield using Bank of Canada research, then applied it to the rise in federal market debt projected in the government’s own debt and GDP forecasts. The figures are annual costs once fully phased in, using today’s debt balances, and each stands on its own rather than adding to the others. I’ll provide the committee with the full methodology in my brief, along with estimates for the questions that two other MPs raised.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *