Opening Statement before the House of Commons Standing Committee on Finance
Stephen Punwasi, Co-Founder and Chief Data Analyst, Better Dwelling.
Ottawa, November 19, 2026.
As prepared for delivery.
Thank you, Madam Chair, and members of the committee.
My name’s Stephen Punwasi, and my background is in behavioural finance and the levers that drive asset prices. I’m also the co-founder of Better Dwelling, Canada’s largest independent housing news outlet, where we focus on reducing information asymmetry.
Information asymmetry occurs when one party is better informed about a transaction than the other. This slants the odds in their favour, helping them to win. Since there’s no shortage of people willing to sing the praises—or fear mongering—over government spending, I’m going to do what we do at Better Dwelling and just explain the market dynamics and risk, hoping it reduces the asymmetry for all parties.
So let’s talk about borrowing, debt, and risks.
There are three things households and policymakers should understand about credit markets.
One: debt is future income, spent today, plus interest.
Borrowing for productive uses can pay for itself. The public is generally in agreement here, and the language Ottawa’s using resonates with that sentiment. However, an investment has to produce a return after its costs, including interest and opportunity costs.
Right now, Ottawa can’t tell us where the money is going. Roughly $260 billion is going to Crown Corporation loans and equity, and the budget doesn’t break down which ones get what. Housing is a good example. The PBO previously said it was unclear if the spending helped or just took credit for things that were happening. Since then, Ottawa ramped up the spending, building costs dropped, and fewer homes are being built. It costs less to build a home, the subsidies have climbed, and fewer are being built. That makes it pretty clear.
The bank grills me if I want to take my own money out for a used car. $260 billion is the equivalent of 16 million Canadian households going to work and paying taxes for a year, but Ottawa won’t tell the public where it’s going?
Two: The Price of Debt Depends On Who’s Borrowing
Debt is priced by supply, demand and risk. Ottawa borrows at the lowest rates in the country, since it runs the printing press. The issue is what happens next. Through its Crown corporations, it passes that cheap credit on to the projects it chooses.
Everyone outside those programs borrows at market rates. Small businesses can’t issue bonds, neither can households. They have to borrow from banks, and according to the latest lending conditions survey, face tighter conditions. Ottawa isn’t just borrowing, it’s helping big businesses succeed, while slanting the odds against the small and medium businesses that employ the majority of Canada’s workers. That’s a subsidy, and like any corporate handout, the public should know what it’s paying for.
Three: Know Your Lender & How Long They’ll Stay
Policymakers have been boasting of the foreign investment made in Canada, but they’ve been light on the details. Let me help with that. Almost zero of the net investment has been in equities. It’s all debt. Foreign investors absorbed all of Ottawa’s net new issuance in the first half of this year. This has created a tail risk that threatens the whole financial system, and I’m not just being hyperbolic. The Bank of Canada has quietly confirmed it.
Hedge funds account for over 40 percent of purchases at auctions, and typically fund those positions with overnight or short-term borrowing. They aren’t lenders the way a household thinks of one. They’re renting the bonds, on borrowed money, a day at a time.
The Bank of Canada warns that a funding disruption could force them to sell suddenly, calling it a “self-reinforcing liquidity spiral.” If I were advising a hedge fund today, I would tell them to make that play too.
During the last crisis, fiscal dominance forced the BoC to buy government bonds to provide liquidity. It was a big payday for investors; the BoC ended up with a $10 billion loss, the equivalent of 625,000 households’ federal taxes for a year.
It will happen again. A crisis for Canadians is a massive win for these foreign investors. Make no mistake, this play is a bet against Canada, not for it. This will be the difference between a recession and a financial crisis.
That backstop keeps Ottawa’s borrowing cheap today. The risk doesn’t go away. It moves to the public.
Is Ottawa making responsible investments for the future of Canada? I don’t know, and anyone who definitively says it is or isn’t is lying. Because Ottawa isn’t sure where the money is going either, it’s like the funds are allocated before anything is actually planned.
I’d ask the committee for three things. First, asset-level reporting for Crown lending and equity, including the subsidy built into below-market loans, so Parliament can see where the spending goes—and the public knows what their kids will be paying for. Second, outcome reporting for conditional transfers like housing. It’s simply not enough to spend money and take credit for wins and blame the economy for the losses. Third, reporting on who holds federal debt, how concentrated that base is, and how much of it is funded with short-term leverage, alongside each budget.
Banks and investors would ask those questions. Parliament—and the public—should be able to ask Ottawa them.
Thank you. I’m happy to take your questions.

Not a good idea to elect a central banker as PM unless you are a banker or real estate developer.
Elbows Up!
Canada saw the global financial crisis and its conclusion was the banks just need to run the country directly.
So, did they ask you questions?
Thank you for the well written, clear breakdown. Transparency is a rare treat these days