US

US Real Estate Enters A Bubble For The First Time Since 2007: US Federal Reserve

US real estate prices are looking frothy, according to central bank researchers. The US Federal Reserve (the Fed) recently updated its exuberance index for Q2 2021. The little-known index exists to identify housing bubbles early, to minimize damage. For the first time since 2007, that indicator is now warning that US real estate prices are in a bubble. Did the Fed even notice? 

The US Federal Reserve Exuberance Index

Exuberance might sound like a good thing, but when economists say it — lookout. If asset buyers are said to be exuberant, they’re excitedly paying emotional premiums. These premiums are above fundamentals, paid because people think prices will always rise. If buyers are exuberant for an extended period, the whole market can become exuberant. Exuberant buyers no longer stand out in contrast to rational buyers. It’s been happening just long enough that people think it’s the new market normal. 

After the US housing bubble nearly took down the global economy, housing became a focus. Previously, experts thought real estate was local. Now they’ve come to learn that exuberant homebuyers can take down a whole economy if left unchecked. Consequently, researchers set out to design this exuberance indicator, to help identify bubbles. 

The exuberance index works by identifying explosive growth in home prices. Explosive growth is just another way of saying growth above fundamentals. The longer a market strays from fundamentals, the greater the odds it needs a correction. If the whole market shows persistent exuberance, it will require a correction to make it efficient. The central bank can minimize the economic fallout by identifying these issues early. 

How To Read The Exuberance Index

The Dallas Fed did all of the hard work, and analysts just have to learn how to read a straightforward data set. We’ve graphed two values — the exuberance indicator and critical threshold. If the exuberance rises above the critical threshold, buyers are exuberant. If the market prints five consecutive exuberant quarters, the whole market is exuberant. An exuberant real estate market is better known as a real estate bubble. 

US Real Estate Has Entered Its First Bubble Since 2005

American real estate buyers are displaying obvious signs of exuberance. The exuberance index read 2.8 in Q2 2021, more than double the 1.37 threshold needed to seem bubbly. The most recent quarter was the fifth above the threshold, making it officially a bubble. Home prices across the US have been on the rise for a few years now, but they’ve only just begun to show exuberant growth. American housing is in its first national bubble since 2007. 

US Real Estate Exuberance Index

The US Federal Reserve Exuberance Index for American real estate, and critical value threshold. A market that is above the threshold for 5 consecutive quarters is considered to be exuberant.

Source: US Federal Reserve; Better Dwelling.

The last time this indicator showed bubble-like behavior was back in 2007. That run first produced a warning from Q1 1998 until finally falling below the threshold in Q3 2007. That’s 39 quarters or 9.75 years for you weirdos that don’t count your kid’s birthdays in dividend payments. Nearly a decade of exuberance caused a bubble big enough to take down the economy in a correction. The most recent five quarters of exuberance look tiny in contrast, don’t they? 

Declaring a bubble after just five quarters might seem early, but that’s the point. The indicators help central banks and policymakers identify them early. By alerting policy makers early, they can act and contain the issue before it gets out of control. The current bubble will be the first time in history that the US has a system in place for an early warning. 

The question is, will they ignore the warning sign? Central banks have become increasingly political, dismissing even their own research. It wouldn’t be surprising to see them gloss over existing warning systems as they did with inflation. Though the “transitory” narrative was retired shortly after they would have seen this data. 

7 Comments

COMMENT POLICY:

We encourage you to have a civil discussion. Note that reads "civil," which means don't act like jerks to each other. Still unclear? No name-calling, racism, or hate speech. Seriously, you're adults – act like it.

Any comments that violates these simple rules, will be removed promptly – along with your full comment history. Oh yeah, you'll also lose further commenting privileges. So if your comments disappear, it's not because the illuminati is screening you because they hate the truth, it's because you violated our simple rules.

  • Jim Sullivan 12 months ago

    Common sense is not so common
    Voltaire

  • Steven Simmons 12 months ago

    Please understand that a “Bubble” doesn’t always mean a coming 2008 foreclosure style market. More like there will be shift in values to a norminalized market. Now if we have huge worldwide economic down turns or another 2008 bond run, all bets are off of what will happen!

    • Thomas 12 months ago

      That’s literally in the article.

      “By alerting policy makers early, they can act and contain the issue before it gets out of control. The current bubble will be the first time in history that the US has a system in place for an early warning. “

  • Kevin 12 months ago

    Beyond the fundamentals?? Aren’t the fundamentals of supply and demand playing out here? You have a limited supply of homes, increase in building supply costs, and worker shortages contrasted with a new generation of new homebuyers, investment buyers and corporations buying up all the available inventory; with extremely high demand and limited supply, then prices go up. It doesn’t get any more fundamental than that, does it? Is that exuberance? And when will this dynamic change, not any time soon, so higher prices in home will continue for the foreseeable. When will the housing supply increase and the demand decrease? It’s anybody’s guess, but with inflation, I can see even more investors wanting to park their money in real estate for a long time.

    • Thomas 12 months ago

      Emotional premiums because of a shortage aren’t a fundamental. It’s a premium to skip the line and take possession today.

      That would be like saying Game Stop’s fundamental value increased 600% because there was a shortage of stock at the moment people wanted it. Value in use is usually a close proximity to wage growth. Unless everyone’s wages in America jumped 20% last year.

  • Miles Johnson 12 months ago

    Is there something similar for the China market?

  • Vicki Lee Reynolds 12 months ago

    They raising prices in housing food and everything that most. Middle income can’t keep up this is now. A high income or be left behind the world is all about. How much you have and how much money you got leaving more than half or Americans out to suffer just to eat and. Try to find a place to sleep this is why god is returning soon. I’m thinking. Before the new year who knows. Only god knows but I’m ready hope all you are you did this. To the world read your bibles

Comments are closed.