Canada

Canada’s Money Supply Growth Is Pointing To A Slower Economy

Canadian households are up to their neck in debt, and it’s showing in the country’s money supply. Bank of Canada (BoC) numbers show the M1+, a measure of the country’s “cash,” is seeing growth slow in February. All signs point to this number heading even lower, and taking economic growth with it as well.

What’s The M1+?

The M1+ is a narrow measure of Canada’s money supply. This number includes currency outside of banks, chequable deposits at chartered banks, trust and mortgage loan companies, and credit unions. In short, it’s anything a person or business can spend in Canadian dollars, with zero to no notice. In the BoC’s own words, the M1+ provides “important information about the economy.”

Important? Sounds important… but how? The BoC manages the growth rate of money indirectly, mostly through interest rate changes. When rates rise, people borrow less and pay more to service debt. The result is less “cash,” which shows up on the growth rate of the M1+. When rates drop, people borrow more and pay less to service debt. More cash for servicing means less cash to spend, and vice versa. The impact is first felt in purchases that usually need financing – like a home or car.

Why Look At The Narrow Supply, Instead of Broad?

The M1+ is one of the more narrow measures of the money supply, as opposed to the M2+ that’s more popular. The M2+ includes more streams of money creation, but doesn’t give us the same insights. M1+ provides insights on future levels of productivity. This helps us understand the direction of things like gross domestic product (GDP). The M2+ includes non-productive credit growth as well, so it’s a better indicator of inflation. High levels of economic productivity are not the same as credit growth.

Slowest February For M1+ Growth Since 1995

The annual pace of growth for the M1+  is slowing. The 12 month pace of growth fell to 3.7% in February, down 11.9% from the month before. This represents a decline of 45% when compared to the same month last year. Yes, it’s really slow growth being printed. In fact, this is the slowest February since 1995.

Canadian M1+ 12 Month Percentage Change

The 12 month percent change of Canada’s M1+.

Source: Bank of Canada, Better Dwelling.

Short-Term Trend Points To Even Lower M1+ Growth

Annualizing a short-term trend and comparing it to a long term, is one way to forecast numbers. A short-term measurement, like 3 months, is made and then projected as if it were the whole year. The 12 month annual pace of growth can’t rise without bigger short-term numbers. For the 12 month to shrink, short-term measurements need to be lower. In short, picture the 12 month trend as chasing those annualized shorter trends. In our last M1+ article, we used the 3-month annualized pace of growth to correctly predict a short-term rise through the winter. Yeah, it’s pretty fly.

The short-term trend is currently pointing to lower annual growth from M1+. The 3 month annualized trend fell to -0.1%, 102% lower than last year. The trend is pointing to a contraction for the 12 month trend. In a truly free market environment, this would be very likely. However, it would be surprising for Canada’s central bank to not step in with a rate cut if this approaches.

Canadian M1+ 3 Month Percentage Change (Annualized)

The 3 month percent change of Canada’s M1+, annualized.

Source: Bank of Canada, Better Dwelling.

Canada’s M1+ is back to shrinking annual growth, with negative growth being observed over the past few months. Annual growth falling to nil without a rate cut is highly unlikely, but that would not be as positive as it sounds. When debt levels are this high, the ability for a rate cut to provide more stimulus is questionable. Odds are the stimulus would be consumed by deleveraging borrowers, not towards productive expansion. Possibly at the expense of a weaker loonie.

Like this post? Like us on Facebook for the next one.

15 Comments

COMMENT POLICY:
We encourage you to have a civil discussion. Note that reads "civil," which means don't act like jerks to each other. Still unclear? No name-calling, racism, or hate speech. Seriously, you're adults – act like it.

Any comments that violates these simple rules, will be removed promptly – along with your full comment history. Oh yeah, you'll also lose further commenting privileges. So if your comments disappear, it's not because the illuminati is screening you because they hate the truth, it's because you violated our simple rules.

  • DD 8 months ago

    It can get slower?

  • Ethan Wu 8 months ago

    “Odds are the stimulus would be consumed by deleveraging borrowers, ”

    Most likely consumed through higher food costs and oil. Oil is prices in CAD, regardless of where it’s sold.

    • Cazador 8 months ago

      I am quite certain that oil is priced in $USD

    • SUMSKILLZ 8 months ago

      I’m tired of ethanol in our gas. Its a rip off. It wrecks fuel economy, and periodically under the right rare circumstances, your engine.

      Gas is up because of “seasonal change over,” “carbon tax,” currency, and markets. Yet its worse than that, they’re selling you an inferior product too. Grrr. I’m sure we’ll see other dilutions too if fuel smashes through $1.70 a litre.

      • Joseph 8 months ago

        Sumskillz, I think it waz you or Blue that opened my eyes to the inferior product. Let’s say costs of car parts go up, we still need cars in Canada, so instead of paying/manufacturing the higher priced parts, an inferior part is used instead.

        I never thought of ethanol as a filler, but you are bang on.

        I bever thought I’d say say this, but imagine a world where the Chinese product is the premium and an even crappier version gets made somewhere else for cheaper.

  • Pookie 8 months ago

    All signs pointing to Steve “Big Short” Eisman making another call, and a buttload of money like he did off the US crash.

    https://moneyweek.com/504059/steve-eisman-2/

    For those that don’t know who he is,

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Eisman

  • Randy — Clebrity Empowerment Coach to the Stars 8 months ago

    Zzzzzzzzzzzzz. I’m asleep. Wake me up when something actually happens.

  • Resident 8 months ago

    I am a regular visitor to Asian supermarkets in the York area for the last 8 years or so and this change is clearly visible to me. No long line ups at the cashier no competition inside the store anymore since last summer. Somewhere else job losses are also reported for March obviously replaced by the part timers hired before march.

    • Joseph 8 months ago

      Sorry for my denseness on what you’re saying. Can you elaborate on your point? What do you infer with not as many shoppers in the Asian stores in York? Have prices gone up there, and that’s why people don’t bother going anymore?

      Please expand if the above wasn’t your point.

      Thanks Resident,

      Joe

      • Resident 8 months ago

        Joe,

        I don’t see a dramatic change in the prices in fact last week felt that the prices have dropped as we spent less for the same grocery list. When I first started noticing the change last summer I thought that this was seasonal and the customers would return once the schools starts which never happened. Now a days checking out is fast and also no long waiting times at the meat dept.. I will do some investigation to see whether a new Asian store has commenced operation. I am also noticing that more and more houses are getting unloaded on Zolo.

        • Resident 8 months ago

          Actually I have been visiting this place on the weekends around the same day and time for the last 8 years.

  • ken 8 months ago

    Great info, but so out of date. July 2018, lots can happen since then.

    • JM 8 months ago

      Mouse over the chart and you’ll see the stats go to Feb 2019

  • Zenity 8 months ago

    I can tell you guys as someone who has direct knowledge of these metrics. The risk indicators are blowing up. We are looking to let go some people, I might be even on the cut list. Banks are not doing well.

    • Nancy 7 months ago

      ?? As someone who has been watching the real estate markets in both Vancouver and Toronto over the past few years I am very confused. The prices have risen and risen despite the warning signs of a rapid downturn in prices or a “pop” of a “housing bubble”. When, if ever, do you predict Toronto will become more affordable?

Comments are closed.