Canada

Bank of Canada Dismisses Data Showing Homes Are Overvalued, But Uses It For Rates

Inflation is transitory… or it may not be. It depends on whether the data is considered reliable enough that day. Bank of Canada (BoC) released a home price exuberance model, showing the market bubbles. Even more interesting is a footnote for the model they used. They feel inflation data on rent is unreliable, because it shows chronic overvaluation. So they dismissed it, despite it being used as a key data point supporting low interest rates. The data is bad when it shows overvaluation, but good when it supports higher home price growth. Oh boy. Let’s dive in.

Bank of Canada Finds CPI Rental Data Shows “Persistent” Overvaluation

The BoC made an attempt to gauge home price exuberance (bubbles), and staff shared the model. Instead of relying on traditional fundamentals, they looked at home price growth acceleration. It’s a commonly accepted method, similar to the one used by the US Federal Reserve. Only minor issues, but all models have some. That’s not the point.

The interesting part is why they opted for this method. Staff intentionally ignored some common fundamental analysis models, because of data reliability. Buried in the footnotes of their research paper was this gem: 

“Alternative approaches to estimating fundamentals — such as those based in the price-to-rent ratio — generate persistent and implausibly large deviations from fundamentals because of the poor measurement of market rents in the consumer price index.” 

That short statement is so jam-packed, it really needs to be dissected to be fully appreciated.

Shelter and Rent Are Very Large Influences On Interest Rates

The central bank has one primary goal — climate change. The best way to fight rising CO2 levels is with a 2.0% mortgage, and $3 billion dollars per week in quantitative ease. Just kidding, despite the central bank saying climate change is now one of their primary goals. The official mandate is actually managing inflation, by keeping it “low and stable,” as they like to say.

The inflation readings are based on the Consumer Price Index (CPI), which has a target rate (currently set at 2%). If CPI is persistently above the target, they move to increase interest rates. If CPI is below target, they move to lower rates, in hopes of stimulating borrowing.

The shelter sub-index is the largest index within the CPI. It represents 26.8% of the basket of goods used to measure the cost of living. The largest sub-component in shelter is rent, representing 6.2 of those points. More simply put, shelter is the largest influence on inflation. Rent is the largest influence on shelter. We have a big problem if the rent data in CPI is useless. 

CPI Shelter Is Much Lower Than Other Measures

It’s difficult to gauge how off shelter and rental data is without looking at the raw data, but you can get an idea. CPI-Shelter increased 3.2% on an annual basis as of April, a substantial jump. Breaking down those numbers, StatCan only has rent increasing by 0.9% over the past year. Not much of an increase. 

Most renters can tell you that is totally off, but more official sources also show that. Canada’s national housing agency estimates primary rental prices are up 3.7% in 2020. The only time CPI rent reached that annual growth level in the past 20 years was one month — October 2019. Other than that, you have to go all the way back to 1991 to see that level of recorded growth. 

It’s easy to see why the Bank of Canada would say it was a “poor” measure. That’s got some interesting consequences though. 

Interest Rates Are Based On CPI, Which Influence Home Prices

The primary tool the BoC has to keep inflation in line is the overnight rate. When inflation operates above the 2% target persistently, they increase interest rates. This reduces the amount of borrowing, by lowering maximum leverage through higher costs. 

If inflation is persistently below the 2% mark, they lower interest rates. This lowers the cost of borrowing, helping people to borrow more. Higher credit capacity allows home buyers to more readily absorb higher home prices. This helps to push home prices higher.

It doesn’t matter how much demand there is, if people can’t afford something — they can’t pay the price. Since affordability is determined by how much one can borrow these days, the maximum available credit is important. More credit influences higher prices, and less influences lower prices.

CPI Rents Are Right When Keeping Rates Low, But Wrong When Showing Overvaluation?

CPI rent component is an accepted truth when determining when to move interest rates. This is despite the fact it is a “poor” measurement of rental prices. Inflation readings are consequently lower than reality. In this case, the underreported CPI supports lower interest rates, and higher home prices. No need to adjust or fix the issue. 

What happens when the same fundamental data shows home prices are overvalued persistently? The CPI rent component isn’t reliable, and chronically produces overvaluation. They dismissed fundamental data that didn’t support higher prices. 

The central bank supports use of the rental data when it supports higher prices. They consider it unreliable when it produces a data point that supports lower prices. Not a total surprise. Even high profile economists have begun to accuse the BoC of not showing their work. It is nice to know that even other departments at the central bank consider the data to be junk though. 

Oh, yeah. Even with the bias towards higher home price growth, the model showed Toronto is a bubble

Like this post? Like us on Facebook for the next one in your feed.

12 Comments

COMMENT POLICY:
We encourage you to have a civil discussion. Note that reads "civil," which means don't act like jerks to each other. Still unclear? No name-calling, racism, or hate speech. Seriously, you're adults – act like it.

Any comments that violates these simple rules, will be removed promptly – along with your full comment history. Oh yeah, you'll also lose further commenting privileges. So if your comments disappear, it's not because the illuminati is screening you because they hate the truth, it's because you violated our simple rules.

  • Fazid 2 weeks ago

    CPI is one of the biggest jokes ever. It’s indexed for pensioners. We base the whole economy on the cost of living for pensioners that already have fixed costs.

    • Paul 2 weeks ago

      Well perhaps all that will change since they are the first generation in their age bracket that will or already have taken on ridiculous amounts of debt. Their pensions will not keep up with inflation because contrary to any belief they too will get hit with high food prices.

  • Parag Agarwal 2 weeks ago

    The only way to make Bank of Canada and its Governor accountable is to have the ruling party ousted. Globally all governments are in cahoots with the Central Banks and doing anything and everything in their power to keep the $ printing machines go brrrrrrrrr. Most citizens are not even realizing that they are stealing from their future generations of children by getting these free checks today. To keep this gravy train going Central Governments who appoint these Central Bankers are unsaid Masters of these shills. It is a sad, sad situation!!

    • Kate Wright 2 weeks ago

      The myth that central banks are independent was really shattered over these past years. Trudeau was just as bad as Trump in this regard, and wanted low interest rates to boost his performance (and pension liabilities).

    • Simon 1 week ago

      Lead the way, I’d like to see you try.

      • Parag Agarwal 1 week ago

        Is that a serious comment? If it is, IMHO politicians should keep themselves out of the economic policy making and leave the Central Banks to do their jobs ACTUALLY independently. The Central Bankers at least had some autonomy at least until the low interest rate environments and the poor political will to correct it sent the world economies down the rabbit hole. The comment is as naive as saying they should Governments should continue to print money to keep people safe at home and then when leave no incentive for them to return because there will always be some fear of contracting infection –basically justifying free money. Smart minds as yourself, could please spare a few minutes of their time trying to explain what is the difference between communism (where government controls everything) and EXTREME socialism where in government takes ownership in private companies, gives handouts to people and businesses and tells them what to do.

  • Marc 2 weeks ago

    Ha! rents are up 0.9% is a good one. In Montreal apartments are sitting empty with lines around the block, and people are bidding up the RENTAL rate. Expect to pay $100 to $200 more than the asking price. This is like a 10 to 20% increase. WHILE IT’S EMPTY.

  • Pepp 2 weeks ago

    The entire world printed tons of money in the last year. Real estate prices will go up, we need to accept this simple dynamic. Its not just Canada, we are going into inflationary cycle. Rents will go up for sure as well and eventually income. Time to prepare yourselves, use your money to buy durable goods or assets that track inflation.

    No one will rise interest rates this time, we are not even starting to recover. No one will kill the economy right now. Face reality and plan accordingly.

  • WS 2 weeks ago

    “No one will rise interest rates this time, we are not even starting to recover. No one will kill the economy right now. Face reality and plan accordingly.”

    Inflation is in the process of killing the economy.
    Asset bubbles like the RE bubbles are the early signs.
    Avoid debt.

  • Simon 1 week ago

    The central bank has one primary goal — MONETARY climate change.

    There, fixed it for you.

Comments are closed.