Bank of Canada’s Delayed Action Means A Hard Landing Is Most Likely: Oxford Econ

Canada’s central bank made its expected rate hike, but the market was still shocked. The Bank of Canada (BoC) hiked the policy rate to 3.25 points today, up 0.75 points from the previous level. Interest rates are now at the highest rate since 2008, and expected to keep climbing due to inflation. Consequently, a hard landing, or recession, is now expected and the odds are against it being a mild one.

The Neutral Policy Rate

For any of this to make sense, you need to understand the basics of policy interest rates. The central bank’s primary role is to ensure low and stable inflation. They do this with one big tool — the policy interest rate.

Central banks have an ideal target range of interest, with the BoC using between 1 and 3 points. If inflation is below 1 point, the BoC might lower rates to make credit cheaper. By doing so, they’re encouraging banks to make more loans to drive inflation, and thus prices higher. That’s where the inflation comes from.

If inflation is above 3 points, they’ll hike rates to cool down the incentive to borrow. This will lower the amount of demand, helping to bring prices down. That’s how they cool inflation — by cooling demand.

The neutral policy rate is the level where interest rates have no influence on inflation. It doesn’t drive inflation or slow it, it’s just right for the level of inflation. You’re going to miss these days, we can already tell.

Here’s the important part for today — BoC research shows it takes 18 to 24 months for policy to arrive to market. If the BoC wanted stable inflation, it was supposed to do it more than two years ago to get the ball rolling. Instead of coming down in a graceful landing, we’re slamming the shifters down, then up, then…  you get it. Trying to force something is almost always worse than encouraging it, but at this point the BoC is stuck. This is a key point to understand the information below.

Canada To Face A Moderate Recession

The BoC is signaling the economy is way overheated, to the point it can be destabilizing to the public. “Today’s statement makes clear that with the economy operating in excess demand, tight labour markets and still elevated inflation, the BoC will press forward with further rate hikes despite its forecast for the economy to “moderate” in H2,” said Tony Stillo, a director of Oxford Economics that specializes in the Canadian economy.

Stillo is no longer entertaining fantasies of a mild recession, like some banks. “In our view, Canada is now likely to fall into a moderate recession by late 2022,” he adds. 

The primary cause, according to the economist, is aggressive monetary policy. By trying to correct inflation in a short period, they need to apply much more pressure than usual. Canada’s highly indebted households amplify the pain in this emergency landing.

He mentions the “deepening housing correction already underway,”  compounding the pain further. Add to that, a global slowdown is fast approaching as well, leading to unknown fallout.

Bank of Canada Expected To Hike Further

Stillo sees the BoC hiking even further in October, bringing the policy rate to 3.75% in just a few months. “From there, we expect mounting signs of a recession in Canada, weakening external demand and continued declines in inflation will cause the Bank of Canada to halt rate hikes,” he says.   

“We now think that such rapid tightening of monetary policy given Canada’s a highly interest sensitive economy, along with a deteriorating external environment, make a recession the most likely outcome for the economy.” 

Waiting too long to act on inflation put the central bank in a tough position. Canada is now witnessing some of the highest inflation ever. A whole generation hasn’t seen anything even close to this.

Had the central bank tackled inflation when it claimed it was transitory, it would be a different story. However, as the BIS pointed out, central banks repeated policy mistakes around the world. This led to synchronization, which leads to larger risk events. Now we’re starting to see why households being highly indebted in a synchronization event is a disaster waiting to happen.

11 Comments

COMMENT POLICY:

We encourage you to have a civil discussion. Note that reads "civil," which means don't act like jerks to each other. Still unclear? No name-calling, racism, or hate speech. Seriously, you're adults – act like it.

Any comments that violates these simple rules, will be removed promptly – along with your full comment history. Oh yeah, you'll also lose further commenting privileges. So if your comments disappear, it's not because the illuminati is screening you because they hate the truth, it's because you violated our simple rules.

  • Mark Bayly 3 weeks ago

    Inflation is double the 7 per cent the government phoney economists are saying because of constantly flooding the economy with worthless printed money It is impossible for inflation to go down to 2 per cent without causing a major long term recession

  • J 3 weeks ago

    Too fishy for it not to be a coordinated delay – just my 2 cp. Good luck everyone – maybe some riots and protests are in the books. PP elected will gut any public funding left in the system. Harper Jr. is here to finish the job. But hey, thems trickle down economics might….. just….. make it down to the hungry and homeless masses… soon. Any day now.

  • Ron Bruce 3 weeks ago

    Tony Stillo, a director of Oxford Economics that specializes in the Canadian economy, uses an ouija board. The ouija board predicts the “deepening housing correction is already underway,” compounding the pain further. Additionally, a global slowdown is also fast approaching, leading to UNKNOWN fallout.

  • richard stanbridge 3 weeks ago

    the article missed out a huge detail. arguably the two most revered economists in the world, larry summers, and mohamed el erian have stated that nobody really knows what the neutral rate is. that being the case that would be like playing the stanley cup with no goals. maybe economists are not the smartest people in the room.

  • Old Greg 2 weeks ago

    Home buyers in recent years are goi g to be wanting to jump like the CFO of Bed Bath and Beyond… You were all trapped it was easy to see the trap at least for me as I sold everything into the mania… This is going to evaporate perceived wealth!

  • Rand Passmore 2 weeks ago

    Yes, we missed the bus in dealing later with inflation. Yes,a recession is now likely, and there are dangers it could be worse than we are anticipating,especially if there are any more severe shocks.
    But before you condemn anyone it is necessary to understand how much we still don’t know about economics and all the things that can happen.

  • Ike 2 weeks ago

    Keep the rate hikes coming BOC! Now I only pay most of somebody else’s mortgage. Not all of it. Thanks!

  • ned 2 weeks ago

    tight labour markets…that is their only real concern of course: can’t have the serfs getting all uppity and being able to demand fair wages and decent working conditions now can we?

  • Ian St. John 2 weeks ago

    Any feedback look with a delay has oscillations. This is no different. The problem is that inflation must be high for a while before the bank of Canada acts. It was apparent that there was pent up demand and supply chain problems a while ago and a ‘precautionary’ adjustment of the interest rate to 2% or more could have ‘dampened’ the swing. But that involves public opinion, not reason so not a possibility in a democracy.

    Just look at how confuse the public is. Such as Mark Baley claiming that the government is ‘printing money’. That is not the way the National Debt works. To increase the ‘money supply’, the government issues bonds (which have value and a rate of return) that are ‘bought up’ by the investors (the current capital pool). That shifts money from the private sector debt to the public sector debt but it doesn’t “print worthless money”

    There needs to be more education in terms of central banks. Too many conspiracy theorists make such claims.

  • Dan 2 weeks ago

    as if a carboard house was ever worth 1 million. you had to be delusional to believe that. good luck fomo losers.

Comments are closed.