Canada

Falling Canadian Home Sales May Lead To Slowing Price Growth Soon: National Bank

Canadian real estate prices are still fast-growing, but showing signs of cooling. The TeranetNational Bank of Canada House Price Index (TNHPI) hit a new record high in July. Annual growth for the index shows acceleration for every month for a whole year now. Signs of cooling exist though, including falling home sales and over half of the index cities underperforming. 

Canadian Home Prices Have Seen Annual Growth Rise Almost 18%

The C11, an index of the country’s largest real estate markets, showed substantial gains. Prices increased 2.0% in July, and are 17.9% higher than the same month last year. It was the 12th consecutive acceleration for the index, and the largest on record. Momentum will carry the index in the short-term, but National Bank of Canada (NBC) observed cooling.

Teranet-National Bank of Canada House Price Index

The 12-month change in the indexed value of home prices in Canada’s 12 largest real estate markets.

Source: TN HPI; Better Dwelling.

Canadian Home Price Gains Shrunk and Sales Are Falling

The index showed price growth acceleration and home sales are both slowing. They note it was the second month to see monthly gains shrink, though they’re still very large. In regards to home sales volume, they also reported a similar situation to CREA — a drop in volume. Over the past few months, sales have tapered consistently, relieving pressure on inventory. NBC economist Daryl King said, “… [this] could mean a slowing of price rises in the coming months.”  

Fewer Than Half of The Index Cities Outperformed For Growth

One interesting point to note here is the index was led by less than half the market in the C11. The cities that outperformed the national index were Halifax (33.4 %), Hamilton (30.1 %), Ottawa-Gatineau (28.9 %), Montreal (21.4 %), and Victoria (21.1 %). These are all relatively small, but high-growth markets — Montreal being an exception.

The other six markets underperformed the national index, and weighed it down. Toronto (17.4 %), Vancouver (17.1 %), Winnipeg (10.5 %), Quebec (10.3 %), Calgary (7.5 %), and Edmonton (6.5 %), came in under. Though Toronto and Vancouver were only slightly under those numbers. 

The TNHPI uses registry data, producing the most accurate measure of growth. This does have one drawback though — it can produce a lag compared to the CREA index. The latter uses market data, but isn’t confirmed for a few months. Since CREA data is showing price growth deceleration, NBC seeing slower price growth coming isn’t totally out there. In fact, it might already be present.

Like this post? Like us on Facebook for the next one in your feed.

14 Comments

COMMENT POLICY:
We encourage you to have a civil discussion. Note that reads "civil," which means don't act like jerks to each other. Still unclear? No name-calling, racism, or hate speech. Seriously, you're adults – act like it.

Any comments that violates these simple rules, will be removed promptly – along with your full comment history. Oh yeah, you'll also lose further commenting privileges. So if your comments disappear, it's not because the illuminati is screening you because they hate the truth, it's because you violated our simple rules.

  • Lumber 2 months ago

    Prices are going down with lumber

  • who knew 2 months ago

    Lumber price was over 1.500 in May 2021, now its only 1/3 of that price with forests burning everywhere. Market is unpredictable.

  • Haha 2 months ago

    Price growth slowing means prices will increase but not as fast. Its different from price decline.
    Overall with all the extra money supply in circulation prices will not decline.

    • Hehe 2 months ago

      The same as was prediction for lumber prices, in May of 2021. Forests are burning, supply is less, lumber price now is one third of it was 4 months ago.
      No one knows when prices stagnate, crash or go up.

    • D 2 months ago

      The extra money will go to paying off debt which destroys money because money is debt. The less debt, the less money, the cheaper houses become because of the less money in circulation. Canadian corporations and individuals are loaded with debt, most are or will be paying it off before the rate hikes. It’s either pay off debts now or get slaughtered with rate hikes. Either way home prices will crash. The suckers born last minute will lose their homes.

  • Honli 2 months ago

    Can anyone explain to me where all of that extra 30% M2 (printed money) will go? Its not going to disappear, asset prices will go up. Please also explain how people with any basic economics education would expect prices to fall?

    • Canaduh 2 months ago

      The folks with advanced economics training are more concerned about those with the basic training who don’t understand modeling limitations and how money actually enters into circulation.

    • alex 2 months ago

      M2 money supply isn’t what inflates real estate valuations, as homes are largely not purchased with cash. Real estate valuations are influenced rather by access to and demand for credit.

      There is a degree of irony here to make such a statement and then question other dwellers’ understanding of “basic economics”.

      • Honli 2 months ago

        Oh, I see you dont make your down payment with cash/M2. Ironic that you keep pointing to economic education.

        • alex 2 months ago

          I said -largely- not purchased with cash.

          As in the vast majority of a home is purchased with credit.

          Which segues back to my point: Real estate valuations are influenced by access to and demand for credit, not so much M2 money supply.

          The actual increase in the M2 money supply averages to around roughly $1000.00 a person. That’s rather insignificant when you look at the fact that mortgage rates have been artificially lowered via BOC involvement to historical lows; to the extent of being lower than the rate of inflation. Meaning borrowers pay negative real interest and are incentivized to borrow as a result. This is where access to and demand for credit is exemplified.

          Does that help you?

    • D 2 months ago

      It’s called wealth destruction, if that money goes to paying off debt it destroys the extra money printed leading to deflation. Example, Japan.

      • Honli 2 months ago

        M2 will not disappear, its basically cash people hold…… That is why I specifically said M2 instead of money supply.

    • Explain 2 months ago

      Explain us how average Canadian family with average Canadian income of 63.000 annual can afford 1.2 million house in GTA?
      1.Slavery for every family member for 25 years.
      2. in slavery for 5 years and give it back to the bank.

Comments are closed.