Canada

Canadian Condos Are Often Overvalued Due To Low Reserve Funds: Report

More Canadians are looking to buy condos, but they’re being warned not all are equal. The Canadian Institute of Actuaries (CIA) released a study on condo reserves this week. In the 140-page report, the organization warns low reserves often create misleading overvaluations. Over the long run those values may not benefit the current owners though. Most condos they looked at had insufficient reserve funds, meaning owners could be hit with bills for tens of thousands of dollars to cover sudden repairs. 

Condo Reserve Funds

Every condo has a reserve fund, a type of account with funds to mitigate the risk of emergency repairs. The funds can be tapped if an expensive or large repair is needed. It’s generally funded by a surplus of maintenance fees and managed by the condo’s board. Some are better managed than others and have stronger reserves, just like any company.

Many Condos Are Suffering From Shortfalls

The CIA found many condos have extremely low reserve funds, to keep maintenance fees low. Buildings targeting investors often boost valuations at the expense of long-term maintenance. “… low reserve fund contributions will likely lead to overwhelming annual increases and require lump-sum payments from owners to cover shortfalls, and could potentially lead to the loss of homes, especially in the context of rising interest rates,” reads the study.

Adding, “This deferral of contributions from current owners to the next buyers will create intergenerational inequity as well as a false overvaluation of the market value of condo properties.”

The study is referencing the impact of carrying costs on home prices. Buildings with low fees leave credit capacity that can add thousands to the price. People will also spend more to be in a building with lower fees. If low fees come at the expense of well-capitalized reserves, value can vanish fast.

Owners can be hit with a special assessment of tens of thousands of dollars. When this occurs, it often happens with very little time to round up the cash. This can mean having to leverage your unit for a home equity loan, or visiting a private lender. Even pricey cities like Toronto can see the value of a condo vanish in almost no time.

New Condos Aren’t Setting Aside Enough Funds For A Rainy Day

The association studied a sample of reserve funds and found many are under saving. “In aggregate, not enough money is being set aside for future expected payments or to cover unexpected repairs,” says Jean-Sébastien Côté, FCIA, and co-author of the paper.

Recent buildings were revealed to be particularly bad. Shiny new buildings often start with low maintenance fees, then require an adjustment. Brand new buildings don’t need much maintenance, after all. They’re also pricey, so people try to save as much as they can. This is a reckless combination. 

If you’re not saving a little when things are good, you can be hit with a big bill when they’re bad. “There are large bills to be paid soon, and very few condos have saved enough, especially those constructed since 2000,” says Côté.

The organization suggests strengthening legislation across Canada to address the issue. Currently there’s a patchwork of provincial legislation, some better than others. This leaves the management of condos largely up to boards with little training. Even worse, they found boards often had undeclared conflicts of interests. Failing the standardization of legislation, they suggest buyers look at reserve studies. They can be obtained for a small fee by anyone, and they often reveal upcoming issues.

2 Comments

COMMENT POLICY:
We encourage you to have a civil discussion. Note that reads "civil," which means don't act like jerks to each other. Still unclear? No name-calling, racism, or hate speech. Seriously, you're adults – act like it.

Any comments that violates these simple rules, will be removed promptly – along with your full comment history. Oh yeah, you'll also lose further commenting privileges. So if your comments disappear, it's not because the illuminati is screening you because they hate the truth, it's because you violated our simple rules.

  • Richard Allen 4 months ago

    My friend bought in Edmonton, around 1999. there was his building, and a second foundation for another building, which was to be (I believe) a separate association. a year or so in, they got assessed for no weeping tile (oops), 20k per unit (which was a lot then, believe me) then assessed AGAIN, for the unbuilt foundation, 20k. they eventually sued, and got the second run back, but it was a painful painful squeeze for a year and a half, and my friend, working two just-slightly-above-minimum-wage jobs, had to go to the bank twice in 6 months to ask for more than half his after tax income from two jobs to keep his condo….

  • David Todtman 4 months ago

    Thank you for the good article. The strategy some condo employ to address the early-years underfunding is simply to sell at about year 8 or 10. The intent is to get out of the corporation prior to the point at which the big ticket items begin to appear. Unfortunately, this is logical in a market system. However, it turns what could be a community of co-operative owners with common interests including maintaining and even enhancing their common property into a system which rewards self-interest. Another tragedy from this is the buildings themselves. Market logic means they break down much earlier than they would otherwise. This is a failure of the market system itself.

Comments are closed.